U.S. War Against Asia |
||||||
United Nations: Flaws and Fixes
|
||||||
|
Popular pages:
|
The earth being murdered while the U.N.'s hands are tiedThe United Nations is a shadow of its former self. More importantly, it is unable to function as a world government that brings peace, prosperity, and environmental stability to the earth and its creatures. The United Nations was founded in 1945, towards the end of World War II. Its charter called for peace, international security, human rights, and the enforcement of international law. It recognizes the sovereignty of individual nations. It asserted the power to mediate disputes between nations and if necessary, to use economic and military means to resolve disputes. It added the lofty goal of encouraging cooperation among nations. In retrospect the U.N. was flawed from its outset. Before describing the flaws, let me add that at time the U.N. has been a positive force for good and has contributed to world peace and other lofty goals. Here I will analyse how and why the U.N. has failed. Failure is obvious if you just take a look at the current global situation. By analyzing the causes of failure I set the stage for suggestions on how to do what is necessary in the future of our beloved earth. Flaws in the U.N.: Veto Powers Given to War-Loving NationsThe structure of the U.N. is based on 193 member states. Palestine has been relegated to the status of an observer state. The Vatican has also been observer state status. Representatives of all these states (1 per nation) meet as the General Assembly. Votes of the General Assembly are non-binding. Much power, however is given to the Security Council. The Security Council acts as the Executive Branch of the U.N. It has most of the power, for instance, only the Security Council can authorize use of force. It has 15 member nations. Ten of those member nations are elected every two years. They are elected on a rotating basis by region. The regions are Africa, Asia-Pacific, Eastern Europe, Latin America, and Western Europe. The permanent members of the Security Council are the main flaw in the organization. This flaw is amplified by the ability of any one member of this council to veto any proposal. So in theory every member of the General Assembly, then every member but one of the Security Council, can vote for an action. One permanent member can shut all of that down. The five permanent members are arguably the evilest nations on earth, based on their histories and the usual definitions of what constitute evil human behavior. They were not chosen by vote or consensus, but were the (alleged) five victorious major nations of World War II: Great Britain (UK or United Kingdom), France, Russia (formerly the USSR), China (formerly Nationalist China) and of course the United States of America. The UK is not that important any more, so it should lose the permanent status based just on that. How did it get the status? Starting in the 1600s it started wars with other nations. By the late 1800s half the world was under its control. Even after the U.N. was founded it tried to keep its colonies subservient. France. What a joke, no reason for permanent status except its exceptionally cruel treatment of its colonies for centuries. Again, after World War II, it tried to re-enslave Algeria, Vietnam, and other nations. China, at least, has the world's second largest economy and second largest population. Despite that, I see no reason it should have veto power over the rest of the world. Russia. A nation now notable only for its viciousness and leftover nuclear weapons. Finally, the United States. My country. Founded by Brits in the 1600s, then purely by wars of defense ended up with almost all former native lands and Hawaii. The only nation to use Atomic Weapons to attack cities of civilians. Cleverly used World War II to take over the former British, French, and German empires. True, it became the greatest economic power, and set up the UN, but does that mean it should be allowed to rule the world, and retain veto power, forever? If you were to select five nations with veto power of the U.N. today, which would you choose? The five nations with the largest populations, per democratic norms? The five with the largest economies? The five with the biggest armies? Or perhaps the five with the best records for ethics and wisdom? So if there is to be a Security Council, let the people of the world elect it. Give no nation the veto power, since we know that is going to be used to allow attacks on other nations without fear of UN intervention. Flaws in the U.N.: Lack of DemocracyThe Assembly of the U.N. suffers from the same type of problem as the U.S. Senate. Representation is not proportional to the number of people represented. The idea that all nations are equal (but the 5 are more equal than others) is nice, but why should a nation of 1 million (or less) have the same representation as a nation of 100 million or more? Flaws in the U.N.: failure to stop warsHere I don't want to dive deep into the history of military action and inaction by the U.N., but the record is poor. One of the early, major interventions was in a civil war, in Korea, with the main consequence that the nation ended up divided into North and South Korea. This happened only because the USSR had walked out of the UN and failed to exert its veto. In much of the rest of the Cold War era with the US or the USSR vetoed intervention or made it clear that a vote on intervention would be pointless. Now we have the Ukraine v. Russia war, for which Russia was veto UN intervention, and the Iran v. U.S. war, for which the U.S. would veto UN intervention (unless the UN decided to back the U.S.) The U.N. should be in a position to stop wars between nations. No nation should be allowed to become an aggressor. Flaws in the U.N.: failure to protect the Earth from environmental harm.Protecting the environment was not one of the original missions of the United Nations. There was some understanding of ecological destruction in the 1940s, but the main threat to the earth was believed to be nuclear weapons. To the extent that the UN has helped prevent a nuclear war since that era, it deserves our thanks. But it turned burning fossil fuels a few drops at a time, done on a massive scale over decades, could be about as much of an Earth killing machine. The U.N. did eventually take up the cause of trying to aid in the protection of the environment, hitting such positive notes as the Paris Accords. They were signed in 2016. This just shows how badly the U.N. needs to be reformed, or replaced. In 2026 the environmental crisis is clear, but the U.S. withdrew from the Paris Agreement, on the orders of the pea-brained subhuman (Homo billionairis) Donald Trump. With no army or other means of enforcement, coming to an inadequate agreement does not amount to much. With a Security Council with two nations that are effectively run by the petroleum extraction industry having the veto power, nothing is likely to happen to stop the human race from its suicidal destiny. The world needs an effective Global Environmental Protection Agency (GEPA). I think most of the world's people would vote for that. GEPA needs to ramp down fossil fuel use as quickly as it can without creating a greater humanitarian crisis. If the U.N. were a real global government, it could quickly create a GEPA. Then it could raise an army and navy sufficient to push all nations to do what is right. But the U.N. is not, effectively, a global government. It is just a global diplomatic talk fest. RemedyIt would not be that hard to form a global government. There are three paths visible. The first thing to try is to have the General Assembly vote to end the veto powers of the Permanent Members of the Security Council. If the Permanent Members accept that change, then the path is clear for the United Nations to bring order and justice to the world, including setting up the GEPA. If the Permanent Members refuse to give up their tyranny, all other members should walk out and join a new organization. It should quickly empower itself to enforce its will on renegade states. That would include setting up GEPA and turning down the fossil fuel industry, as well as other industries and practices that harm the global environment. And it the current states refuse to do that, or if only a few want to do that, the people themselves should form a Provisional Government of Earth with a Global Environmental Protection Agency. Or we and our descendants can just wait around to die of global warming, famine, and chaos. |
|||||
| III Blog list of articles |
|
|||||